• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

I Like Kill Nerds

The blog of Australian Front End / Aurelia Javascript Developer & brewing aficionado Dwayne Charrington // Aurelia.io Core Team member.

  • Home
  • Aurelia 2
  • Aurelia 1
  • About
  • Aurelia 2 Consulting/Freelance Work

A Proposal For A Better Online Voting System

General · April 14, 2014

Hacker News, Reddit and Stack Exchange all share a similar trait with one another: voting. You can either up-vote or down-vote depending on restrictions the site has in place. Social voting systems are inherently flawed and subject to manipulation.

Just a little food for thought:

  • Limit the number of up-votes a user has per day. If up-voting is more scarce, people will selectively be more careful with how they spend their votes.
  • Limit the number of votes a user can perform in a 10 minute period. Imposing limits on the speed of voting means a user will be even more selective with how they up-vote content.
  • If a particular piece of content makes it to the homepage (for example on Reddit or Hacker News) a user should be awarded X amount of up-votes to their quota which they can spend. This award value would be capped to prevent hoarding.
  • Voting history is public. All votes a user has performed should be public: both up and down-votes. This will mean a users voting activity is public and thus will help reduce spam/gaming of the site.
  • Possibly difficult: but a problem with a lot of voting systems, especially for social link sites is that people up and down-vote based on titles without clicking through to the content. Either checking if the user visited the link or imposing a timer before a user can vote would also help.
  • Down-voting costs karma/points. Stackexchange already do this on all of their Q&A websites, other sites should adopt this approach. If you disagree with a submission, maybe leaving a comment is a better idea than down or up-voting it.
  • The more selective a user is with votes, the weight their vote has. If a user has voted a lot, their votes should less weight than that of someone who votes more carefully.

Dwayne

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Primary Sidebar

Popular

  • Testing Event Listeners In Jest (Without Using A Library)
  • How To Get The Hash of A File In Node.js
  • Web 3.0 may have died before it even started
  • Smoke Detector Randomly Goes Off Early Hours of The Morning
  • NBN Box Installed Inside of Garage, Where Do You Put The Modem?
  • How to Copy Files Using the Copy Webpack Plugin (without copying the entire folder structure)
  • How To Install Eufy Security Cameras Without Drilling or Using Screws
  • How to Use Neural DSP Archetype Plugins With the Quad Cortex
  • How To Calculate A Javascript Date X Months Ago With Vanilla Javascript
  • Which Neural DSP Archetype Plugins Should You Buy?

Recent Comments

  • Casey Milne on A List of WordPress Gutenberg Core Blocks
  • Jay on Neural DSP Reveal Details About the Long-Awaited Quad Cortex Desktop Editor
  • john on Deno Raises $21M – but is anyone using it yet?
  • Oranges on How To Store Users In Firestore Using Firebase Authentication
  • Precious on Fixing Sequel Pro SQL Encoding Error For Imported SQL Files

Copyright © 2022 · Dwayne Charrington · Log in

wpDiscuz